January Menu

All 9″ pies come in a reusable PIEfection tin. There is a $1 deposit required, but bring the tin back, and get a $1 on your next pie. Just don’t wash them in your dishwasher!

* Denotes seasonal items.

Not all pies are available every day. Call to confirm availability, or place an order to ensure that your favorite pie will be waiting for you!

Pie of the Month:

Turtle Cheesecake 25

A chocolate cookie crust is filled with rich, creamy cheesecake, topped with homemade caramel

and pecans, drizzled with chocolate, and finished with a halo of real whipped cream.


Orchard Fruit Pies

Country Apple 14 (Also available Gluten Friendly with 24 hr. notice)
Just like you wish mom used to make! A perfect blend of apples, freshly ground nutmeg, and cinnamon spice.
Triple Berry 16
A medley of Blackberries, Raspberries, and Marionberries
Wild Blueberry 17
Wild, uncultivated blueberries make this flavor out of this world
The Georgia Peach 16
sweet baked peach pie; a taste of the south
Michigan Cherry 16
Ripe, tart cherries baked into a delicious buttery crust. Get your vanilla ice cream ready!

Strawberry Rhubarb 16

Tangy Rhubarb mingling with sweet, ripe strawberries

Boysenberry Pie 19

Ripe Boysenberries are perfectly sweetened and baked in a double Piefection crust until golden brown. Perfect on its own or with a scoop of ice cream.


No Sugar Added Orchard Fruit Pies

Our traditional Fruit Pies without the added sugar.

*Only available by special order. Place orders online, in store, or by phone.

No Sugar Added Country Apple 18

No Sugar Added Georgia Peach 18

No Sugar Added Michigan Cherry 18

French Crumb  Pies

Our traditional fruit pies, finished with a buttery streusel crumb topping.

Country Apple Crumb 15

Michigan Cherry Crumb 17

Triple Berry Crumb 17

Georgia Peach Crumb 17

Wild Blueberry Crumb 18

Rich  and  Creamy  Pies

All our cream pies are topped with real whipped cream

Coconut Cream 15 (Also available Gluten Friendly with 24 hr. notice)
Banana Cream 17 (Also available Gluten Friendly with 24 hr. notice)
Chocolate Cream 14 (Also available Gluten Friendly with 24 hr. notice)
Black And White 15
A Double layered chocolate and rum cream pie
Lemon Sour Cream 17
Tangy lemon base covered in a sweet sour cream layer.
Triple Berry Sour Cream 19
Triple Berry pie on the bottom, topped with a sweet sour cream layer.
Cherry Sour Cream 19
Michigan Cherry Pie on the bottom, topped with a layer of sweet sour cream.

Cheesecake Pies

A layer of rich cheesecake topped with our premium fruits

Cherry Cheesecake 23

Triple Berry Cheeecake 23

Blueberry Cheesecake 23

Local Lemon Cheesecake 23

*Fresh Strawberry Cheesecake  26  (Seasonal: Usually March-Sept)

Mesa Citrus Pies

Lemon Meringue 17
Tangy Lemon bottom, topped with heavenly tufts of toasted meringue.
Key Lime Pie 18
Key Lime citrus custard in a graham cracker crust

Custard  Pies

Custard Pie 14

An old fashioned favorite gets an update in our smooth custard with freshly ground nutmeg.

Coconut Custard Pie 15

Classic custard in a flaky Piefection crust with creamy coconut and a real whipped cream halo.

Signature  Pies

Piefection specialties.

Southern Pecan 20
A sweet southern classic

Kentucky Derby 21

Our Sweet Southern Pecan gets a layer of dark chocolate chips added to it. Not for anyone on any kind of diet.

French Silk 22
Callebaut Chocolate decadence. Silky, dark, and sinful. Topped with Whipped Cream & Chocolate Shavings.

Lemon Blueberry Sour Cream 19
Bright lemon meets our Wild Blueberry Sour Cream Pie.

White Chocolate Raspberry 19
Creamy White Callebaut Chocolate and Raspberries. Need we say more?

Almond Joy 19

Decadent and sweet coconut confection filled with chocolate chips and almonds, baked to golden perfection in a flaky Piefection crust.

Peanut Butter Dream 20

A rich White Callebaut Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse in a chocolate cookie crust drizzled with chocolate, and topped with real whipped cream.

Arizona Orange Pie  20

Freshly picked sour Arizona oranges are juiced in house to make this delicious pie. It’s a creamy, tangy specialty you will only find here. If you like Key Lime pie, you will LOVE the Arizona Orange.

German Chocolate Pie 19

Guittard Chocolate Cream with Coconut, Pecans, and chocolate chips. Topped with a flurry of Real whipped cream, and sprinkled with chocolate chips and pecans. It’s our newest customer favorite.

Seasonal Pies

Only available seasonally. Call to confirm availability.

*Caramel Apple 19
Tangy green Granny Smith apples meet rich, silky homemade caramel in this taste of fall. It’s topped with a drizzle of caramel that makes it almost as pretty as it is delicious. Try it with ice cream.

*Fresh Strawberry Pie 23

Fresh strawberries in a sweet glaze fill our flaky Piefection crust, topped with a halo of real whipped cream.


Savory Pies

Turkey Pot Pie 6.5

Chicken Pot Pie 6.5 

Italian Beef Pot Pie 7.5

Green Chile Pork Pot Pie 7

Pizza Pot Pie 7

Family Chicken Pot Pie 17 (sold frozen for home baking unless otherwise requested)

Comfort food at it’s best. Breast Meat, carrots, peas, and fire roasted corn in delicious gravy. Tonight’s dinner is served.

Family Green Chile Pork Pot Pie 19 (Sold frozen for home baking unless otherwise requested)

Flaky Piefection crust filled with tender braised pork, fire roasted corn, and flavorful pinto beans in a delicious green chile sauce.

Ham and Cheese Quiche 17

Mediterranean Quiche 17

Broccoli and Bacon Quiche 17

Fresh Buttery Dinner Rolls

Freshly baked dinner rolls are the perfect accompaniment to your pot pie, sold in packs of 6.

White Rolls 4.5

Wheat Rolls 4.5 (Special Order Only)

**Allergen alert: Piefection pies are made in a facility that processes nuts, including Peanuts and Pecans.

***Our pie selection varies daily. Place orders to ensure your favorites will be available, or call to check today’s selection. 480.218.PIES (7437)