faqs
General
Can I place an order?
You can place an order for these pies:
Custard or Coconut Custard
No Sugar Added Apple
No Sugar Added Cherry
No Sugar Added Peach
Gluten Free Chocolate
Gluten Free Coconut
Gluten Free Banana
Gluten Free Apple
Gluten Free Cherry
Boysenberry
Rhubarb Only
Keto Pie
Please call our store if you would like to order any of these pies, as they cannot be ordered through our website.
All other pies are sold on a first come first served basis. If you have a hankering for a specific pie, come early for the best selection.
How are your pies different than any other pie?
Our pies cannot be compared to a grocery store pie. We bake fresh everyday. We do not use additives or preservatives. We use only the finest ingredients.
We make EVERYTHING from scratch, including our crust, our whipped cream, all our fruit fillings and our pastry cream. We make our own gravies for our pot pies and we also roast our own meats.
We import our chocolate from Belgium, our cherries from Michigan, our peaches from Georgia, our apples from Washington, our wild blueberries from Maine, and our berries from Oregon.
We ONLY use fresh whipped cream, we do not use faux whipped cream and we make it several times per day! We only use butter in our crumb topping and in our graham cracker crust no imposters!
How fresh are your pies?
We bake EVERYDAY so they are as fresh as you can get them. Sometimes they are still hot when you pick them up!
The only exceptions are our Take and Bake Pot Pies and Quiches. Take and Bake Pies we freeze so they are ready to be baked at home at your convenience.
How do I care for my pies?
All pies with fresh whipped cream
Eat within 48 hours, due to FRESH WHIPPED CREAM.
All Fresh Fruit (Strawberry and Peach) Pastry Cream Pies
Consume within 36 hours; fruit will make pastry cream runny after that.
Cheesecake with Berries
Eat within 36 hours to maintain fresh berries.
Fresh Peach
Eat within 24 hours as peaches turn brown quickly.
Banana Cream
Eat within 36 hours and eat entirely after slicing.
French Silk and Peanut Butter Dream
It should be sliced in small pieces since it is SO rich.
Turtle Cheesecake
Bring to room temp before slicing.
Pecan and Kentucky Derby
DO NOT refrigerate.
Brownie Pies
Bring to room temperature before slicing.
How long do your pies last?
Because we do not use additives or preservatives, our pies have a much shorter shelf life than others. Generally speaking, our cream pies have a 2-3 day shelf life and our shelf stable fruit pies have a 5-6 day shelf life.
Do I need to refrigerate my pies?
Anything with whipped cream must be refrigerated. Do not refrigerate Southern Pecan or Kentucky Derby.
Do you have any vegan pies?
Yes, just request our fruit pies baked with no egg wash.
Can you make a dairy free, gluten friendly pie?
Our GF crust contains butter, so it cannot be dairy free.
Do you use lard in your pie crust?
No, we use an all purpose shortening made with canola and palm oil.
What pies freeze well?
All our double crust fruit pies freeze well. Additionally, our Southern Pecan and Kentucky Derby, both freeze well. Our Key Lime, Arizona Orange, Cheesecakes and French Silk can all be frozen if you request it without fresh whipped cream.
Our Take and Bake Pot Pies and Quiches are sold frozen so those you can keep frozen till you are ready to eat them.
Why do you call it Gluten Friendly and not Gluten Free?
Gluten Free is made in a dedicated facility free of any gluten flour. Our facility is not dedicated to gluten free, but we do our best to control any cross contamination by using a clean, sanitized work area, and clean and sanitized utensils.
How many slices can you get out of a pie?
We slice in 6 slices.
What size are your pies?
Our pies are 9-inch pies, that includes all of our family sized pies. Our mini pies are 6 inches, and our sweet tarts are 4 inches.
What pies have nuts in them?
Our Southern Pecan, Kentucky Derby, Peanut Butter Dream, Peanut Butter Brownie and German Chocolate pies all contain nuts. Some seasonal options may include nuts, along with our Cherry filling and White Chocolate Pastry cream contains almond extract. Please call and inquire regarding any and all allergies.
What sweetener is used in our No Sugar Added pies?
We use monkfruit to sweeten our NSA pies which is considered the non sugar premium sweetener!
Can PIEfection pies be customizable?
There are several pies that we can make customizable. Here are a few we have done in the past:
-Coconut Meringues
-Chocolate Meringues
-Gender reveals with cheesecakes, Banana Cream, or Boston Cream
-Peach Cheesecake
Give us a call to see if we can make your idea could happen!
Can you ship pies?
Yes we ship pies! You can call our Mesa location to have a pie shipped. The cost is the cost of the pie, handling fee and shipping fee!
Additionally, we partner with Goldbelly, a premium food shipper, to ship nationwide with select pies
Can you write a message on a pie?
We cannot write a message on a pie, but we have these options to purchase to make it special:
-Birthday Candles
-Card
-Gift wrap